Ken Lumb and Anne Plumb's grassroots archives

Slide 1 - Introduction (Slide 2) - Slide 3 Ken Lumb - Slide 4 Anne Plumb - Slide 5 Going? or archive?- Ken's archive (Slide 6 Ken's background) - Slide 7 Rochdale sculpture - Victor Finkelstein and the Union of the Physically Impaired Against Segregation - ~~ Slide 8 more from 1970s - Rochdale Voluntary Action - Slide 9 1980s - 1981 International Year of Disabled People - Slide 10 Arts and Cuba - Slide 11 Coalition magazine - Anne's archive [Catalogue] - Slide 12 Early collection - Slide 13 - Slide 14 - Slide 15 - Slide 16 - Slide 17 Press cuttings - Slide 18 - Slide 19 Survivor History Group - Slide 20 Archives and history -

I am going to talk about two grassroots archives linked to two social and political movements.

* disability movement

* mental health movement

First a definition by the Union of the Physically Impaired Against Segregation in 1976.

Disability is the disadvantage or restriction of activity caused by a contemporary social organisation which takes little or no account of people with physical impairments and thus excludes them.. Physical disability is, therefore,a particular form of social oppression.

And a definition form the Mental Health System Survivors policy statement in 1987

"Mental health' system survivors are people who are neither 'crazy' nor 'mentally ill' nor genetically distinguishable from anyone else..Rather we have been victimised by the 'mental health' system because of our hurts and the hurts of those around us. Because in trying to get help in the only ways or places we know of, because we belong to certain oppressed groups, or refuse to fulfil some of society's prescribed roles, or protest the wrongs of society , we became involved in the 'mental health' system."

Definitions are controversial . Diversity, however, gives balance to archives. Their potency often lies in their focus.


Self portrait

Middleton: Greater Manchester

Ken Lumb 1941-2009

Disabled activist

The first archive is that of Ken Lumb, a long time disabled activist. There will be many of these sorts of archives in people's house. Someone joins an organisation, keeps annual reports and press cuttings, joins an executive committee, accumulate minutes, correspondence, reports. Keeps them in a pile, files, or boxes in the loft.

Ken's files are themed - housing, helper/helped relationship, mobility and access, charity, genetics and reproductive technology..and so on In addition to relevant publications are two set of magazines, Scope and Coalition which I will return to. .

Anne Plumb 1946-

Mental Health System Survivor

The second archive is my own, covering mostly the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s. This is a more specialised archive

I started taking press cuttings, picking up leaflets at conferences, then buying booklets I came across through newsletters ,and as a distress awareness trainer, purchasing reports and books.

There are two sections to my archive.

The first I've named Ear to the Ground. Survivor and Ally Voices:

Organisation and Action. This comprises 3 files in chronological order and additional extracts from these items.50+ booklets and reports and 20+ books whose authors are largely survivors/services users plus associated books.

I also have magazines and newsletters, a couple of these are almost complete sets (Asylum magazine and Hearing Voices Network newsletter.)

The other is supplementary files on survivors perspectives, psychiatry and service provision.

One in a hundred

Aidan Schindler whose art work I've shown is a survivor artist and activist. In 1 in 100 ,a person diagnosed with schizophrenia is a butterfly. The remaining 99 are a well known psychological ink blot. After some deliberation I was given the label of manic depressive psychosis rather than schizophrenia so I am a blob not a butterfly!


TEXT HERE

FUTURE for Grassroots Archives

DISPERSAL - LOFTS - BIN LINERS - SKIPS?

(ageing activists, organisations folding)

OPEN QUESTIONS

  • What is the significance of grassroots archives
  • What are the problems with such archives
  • Does the loss of grassroots archives matter
  • If so, what is being lost
  • The relationship to academic accounts of grassroots activism
  • How can such archives be conserved and made accessible
  • What are the practical problems eg copy right, confidentiality.

    I am going to provide a glimpse of these archives leaving open a number of questions as to the significance of these archives, associated problems, their loss as activists age and organisations fold. what the loss means regarding academic accounts of grassroots activism, how such archives may be conserved and made accessible and the practical problems of copyright, confidentiality etc.

    There is the Disability Unit at Leeds University But conserving the archives of mental health activists is complicated as some of us do not see ourselves as having mental impairments and believe that we should be in alliance with the disability movement rather than absorbed by it. The Wellcome institute has National Mind's archive but some activist do not like the association with the drug companies. And some organisations want to keep their archives local.(Tower Hamlets African and Caribbean Mental health organisation)

    Background to Ken Lumb's archive

    I am just going to give a little background to Ken Lumb's archive. Ken was born in Rochdale, part of greater Manchester.

    Childhood Looking out from Ken Lumb's backyard onto neighbouring terrace. Rochdale, Greater Manchester

    The photograph shows the backstreet to the house where his family lived, where his brother's three wheeler was parked.

    Ken remained true to his working class roots although he moved on in some ways, obtaining , over 8 years work, a degree through the Open University. Encountered the Fronte Radicale Invalidi on a Study Tour to Rome in March 1977 (detailed access posters fly posted and direct action closing part of the old town)

    November 1964

    A second photograph shows Ken Lumb (right) aged 23, his brother Brian Lumb and friend on a Holiday in a Butlins camp organised by the Red Cross in November 1964.

    Most of Ken's archive from the 1940s to 1960s are photographs. But there are a couple of magazines, Magic Carpet from the Disabled Drivers Association in which he was active and Progress from the Disablement Income Group.

    An account of the Disabled Drivers Association (1960s) is given in Tony Baldwinson's Unacknowlged Traces; Exploring through photographic records the self- organisation of disabled people from the 1920s to the 1970s.

    See Wikipedia Disabled_Motoring_UK

    Rochdale Sculptures

    In the early 1970s Ken was secretary to the Rochdale Sculptors, a radical group. One member, Walter Kershaw, painted a mural on a wall at UMIST I think it was.

    The picture shows Rochdale Sculptors (and artists) leaving Ellen Smiths on their Grand Tour.

    "From the late 60s until they split in 1974, the Rochdale Sculptors often took their work outdoors to bring it directly to members of the public, targeting viewers with little or no experience of art. Their sculptures regularly appeared along the Esplanade and in other parts of the Borough as well as other locations in the region. They also exhibited indoors at Rochdale Art Gallery and other galleries and venues including the Houses of Parliament."

    Ken Lumb's own cartoons and some of his artwork was political. See, for example, the covers of Scope magazine

    SCULPTORS ... Walter Kershaw, Christine Pearson, Danny Milne, Robin Forrester, Ken Lumb, Barry Hobson, Tony Smart and Peter Wolstenholme.

    Manchester Evening News

    The Rochdale Sculptors were formed in 1968 by Peter Wolstenholme and Tony Smart who at the time were lecturers at Rochdale College of Art. More tutors at the college soon became involved and the group grew to include other artists, some of whom had no direct connection with the college or Rochdale. (source)

    Ronald Gorton Day Centre

    Ken was also an occasional visitor to the Ronald Gorton Day Centre for Elderly and Disabled People where I was working as a cleaner and dinner lady.

    The picture above shows the desertaed centre in the winter of 2012/2013, when it was for sale and development. source

    Initially, Ken took part in snooker matches but then became involved in establishing a Housing and Disability group, a Mobility and Access group, a Holiday Group and producing a magazine Scope. (1972-1976).

    See Anne Plumb 1970. Anne and Ken married in 1977

    A photo of Brian now in Majorca - a collaboration of the Holiday group and a local Travel Agent ( Brian was a regular visitor and involved in clubs that used the centre.)


  • Scope Magazine. Ronald Gorton Centre 1972-1976

    The Editorial team of Scope magazine produced 16 copies - 1972-1976 with a print run of 500. Provided information and comment. Front covers illustrated by Ken.

    There is a press cutting here of the magazine group with the duplicator - compliments and brickbats for council! (duplicator kept in the first aid room)

    Spring 1975

    Victor Finkelstein and the Union of the Physically Impaired Against Segregation

    The Magic Carpet Quarterly magazine (1948 on) of the Invalid Tricycle Association, which became the Disabled Drivers' Association in 1963. ISSN 0047-5475

    The editions of the Disabled Drivers Asssociatuon's journal Magic Carpet in which Vic Finkelstein first published the definitions which became a basis for the UK disability movement. See Finkelstein New Year 1975: "Phase 2: Discovering the Person in 'Disability' and 'Rehabilitation'" and March 1975 "More on phase 2"

    During this same period Ken joined the Union of the Physically Impaired Against Segregation and, as I often accompanied him as a helper I became an Associate member.

    Rochdale Voluntary Action

    Constitution adopted 20.3.1975 - Registered as a charity 3.6.1976 - On 27.3.1997 the name changed to the Council For Voluntary Service, Rochdale

    The Ronald Gorton Day Centre management decided that the Housing and Mobility groups were non bon fidae, so they moved to Rochdale Voluntary Action where Ken also became involved in its management.

    Rochdale Voluntary Action
    Management
    Meetings and Campaigns
    Rochdale Housing and Disability Group
    Rochdale Mobility and Access Group

    Picture: Rochdale Voluntary Action: Ken Lumb chair

    This is a selection of items relating to these activities

    Mobility

    Opportunity

    Believe in oneself

    Independence

    Livelihood

    Integration

    Yes

    A photo of local activists supporting the national trike and mobility campaign for small car.

    Ken wrote a piece 'Little Blue Things remembered' expressing affection for the 'Noddy Cars' and the independence they bought especially to young people despite how dangerous they were. (Mobility Allowance (1976) often goes towards a family car and young people do not always have the same independence) - See link


    20.9.1977

    A press report on opposition to the building of a young disabled unit at Birch Hill hospital. Despite opposition by disabled people to these segregated units the government was putting vast sums of money into the programme.

    1978

    The report of a Housing Research Project looking at the way housing provision disabled people.

    Housing and Disability: A report on the housing needs of physically handicapped people in Rochdale by Bill Finlay; Rochdale Voluntary Action. 157 Drake Street, Rochdale OL11 1EF

    It's an Uphill Struggle - a drawn out campaign to ensure disabled people could access Rochdale's main shopping centrte once it was pedestrianised. If anyone knows Rochdale, this is a up a steep slope.

    1980s

    In the 1980s, Ken retained links with Rochdale - with the Disabled Persons Working Party but I have no record - but became closely involved in Greater Manchester.

    1981 International Year of Disabled People

    Ken became a fieldworker with the Greater Manchester Council for Voluntary Service (history), charged with organising things for the International Year of Disabled People (1981)

    The International Year of Disabled People brought together activists in the various Greater Manchester boroughs who had shared concerns, setting up the Greater Manchester Housing and Disability group, the Greater Manchester Mobility and Access group (still in existence today) and the Greater Manchester Coalition of Disabled People (1985). The GMCDP had close links with the Derbyshire Coalition of Disabled People and Derbyshire Centre for Integrated Living

    GMCDP produced a magazine Coalition

    Set up a Young Disabled people's project.

    There's a postcard from the Young Disabled Persons Project - I am not special, I am not brave, I am a disabled person and my name is John.

    1985

    Finally, the UPIAS study tour to Cuba which was a reminder that you can't just transpose ideology from one country to another where circumstances are very different despite similarities in politics.

    KEN DECIDED NOT TO DUPLICATE MATERIAL BY KEEPING IT AT HOME WHEN IT WAS STORED AT THE GREATER MANCHESTER COALITION OF DISABLED PEOPLE OFFICES. THE MATERIAL IS NOW MOSTLY KEPT AT THE GMCDP OFFICES APART FROM 'COALITION' MAGAZINE

    1986

    Ken Lumb and Hazel at St. Anne's on Sea in 1986

    Wrote 'Baby Hazel' on finding a charity box in St. Anne's -baby in palm of hand /

    Greater Manchester Coalition of Disabled People 1985 -

    "In July 1985 an event was held at County Hall, Manchester, for disabled people, which was attended by 100+ people. At the end of this meeting a vote of confidence was given to try and form a Coalition of Disabled People in Greater Manchester. The discussions from this meeting formed the aims, objectives and constitution of the Coalition." (source)

    Links with similar organisations:
    Derbyshire Coalition of Disabled People
    Derbyshire Centre for Integrated Living (CIL)

    Protests .

    Produced magazine Coalition 1986-

    Reflected the political action and debates of Of the day .

    Young Disabled People's Project


    Coalition magazine grew out of the GMCDP newsletter, produced quarterly. The initial editor was Ian Stanton (1951-26.11.1998)

    Ian was GMCDP's Information worker and , in some disability circles, reknowned singer song writer. Eg I'm a Crip with a Chip was played at ken Lumb's tribute.

    After Ian's death, Ken took over as editor.

    The magazine is now being produced with guest editors.

    A member of GMCDP is currently working on a data base to record and make the magazines accessible as they are an important record of disability action and debate.

    The GMCDP archive has been under threat over the years.

    Loss of funding for the their Information project;
    downsizing which meant a cull of the archive;
    loss of core-funding and premises this year though funding for the Young Disabled persons Unit is secure for the time being. But funding remains for a project to digitilise the video collection.


    These are some of the activities of the UPIAS and the GMCDP in the 1980s

    1986 Triggering the cancellation of an Arts event, Artability, proposed for Manchester by the 'great and the good' in the Arts world but they neglected to talk to organisations of disabled people in Manchester.

    The Artability event was cancelled when the Carnegie Foundation decided they did not want to be involved in this dispute and withdrew funding.

    1987 Disabled people held their own Arts Conference which led on to discussions on Disability Culture.

    In January 1988, supporting Nabil Shaban, a disabled actor, in a protest outside Granada studios when he was turned down as a children's presenter as being "too frightening" (see)

    Farewell to long-time disability activist Ken Lumb Ken Lumb was one of the early founders of the UK disabled people's movement. We report his recent death with great sadness. I don't think he would have called himself a 'leader', but I think he was one in the best sense. He was an inspiration and a source of great wisdom, experience and knowledge. Most of all, for me, he was a person of great determination, commitment and experience.

    In a world where disabled people and other service users face routine discrimination, oppression and double-dealing, he was principled and always kept in sight the ideals of the disabled people's movement - to achieve people's rights and bring about broader change in society.

    Ken had a long association with the Greater Manchester Coalition of Disabled People, which is how I got to know him and, especially important I believe, he was editor of its journal or magazine, Coalition. Coalition is one of the things that keeps me going. Loads of humour, but also real honesty and no pretence. For me it was the disabled people's equivalent of Private Eye, telling truths others didn't mention and helping you to feel you weren't on your own.

    We send every good wish to his partner and survivor activist Anne Plumb and daughter Hazel on their sad loss. We won't forget the contribution of people like Ken.

    Peter Beresford

    Chair, Shaping Our Lives

    Shaping Our Lives Newsletter Spring 2009 Issue 15


    Anne Plumb

    I guess I could be defined during my time within the psychiatric system in the late 1960s as a service resister.

    This does not mean I have not needed sanctuary or support either personal and in making sense of my experiences but that my experience of psychiatry was traumatic, abusive and not helpful.

    So I began collecting stuff I came across that reflected this resistance.

    One item on slide 12 - State and Mind - I came across in Manchester's Grassroots Bookshop in the mid 1970s [After 1978].

    PROMPT Booklet8/9 (1981), with my signature coffee stain,

    Akimbo, a Manchester Mind number on unwanted effects of drugs

    Your Rights in Mental Hospital (about 1979) also picked up in Grassroots Bookshop at this time, is shown on slide 13. It was a Manchester Mental Patients' Union pamphlet, supported by Manchester University Community Action, Manchester Area Resource Centre, Manchester Big Flame, Grass Roots Books

    Later publications shown are the first issue of Asylum belong to the 1980s.

    My copies of Perceptions and Solo Survivor were given to me by other survivors/service users from their collections.

    Newsletters, in my collection include Survivors Speak Out - I was member from 1987 to late 1990s when the organisation changed substantially - and subscribed to the Hearing Voices Network.



    Slide 13.:

    I'll just a say a bit about two or three of these.

    Power in Strange Places, published by Good Practices in Mental Health in 1987, contains articles of user empowerment at the time (Chesterfield, Camden, Nottingham)

    Direct Power. Joint publication by Brixton Community sanctuary,Community Support Network, Pavilion Publishing and MIND. A resource pack for people who want to develop their own care plans and support networks. 1994

    Whose service is it Anyway? Research and Development for Psychiatry Institute publication 1990 1990, arose when it was pointed out that the RDP had extensive consultative links but had not sought the opinion of service users


    Slide 14: Books include

    Aidan Schindler, Beyond Reason, a catalogue of an exhibition.

    Survivor Poetry, Under the Asylum Tree, 1994

    Janet Frame's autobiographical novel, Faces in the Water

    DerbyshireVoice: On the receiving End , The emotional and psychological impact of Psychiatric Assault

    MIND,Finding Our own Solutions, Women's experience of mental health. 1988

    Jim Read and Jill Reynolds, OU set book, Speaking our Minds; 1996

    Peter Lehmann ed. Alternatives to Psychiatry.

    Varous eds. Living with Voices. 50 stories of Recovery


    slide 15: Some of the organisations with an entry in my files.

    ORGANISATIONS : survivor, service-user, ally
    Leaflets ,press cuttings, conference flyers, articles
    (PERSONAL SAMPLE)

    ALLEGED LUNATICS FRIEND Society 1845-1863

    LUNACY LAW REFORM SOCIETY 1873-1885

    PATIENTENVERTROUWENSPDSOON (Holland)

    MENTAL PATIENTS LIBERATION FRONT (USA)

    NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF PSYCHIATRIC SURVIVORS (USA) NAPS

    MENTAL PATIENTS UNION

    CAMPAIGN AGAINST PSYCHIATRIC OPPRESSION

    BRITISH NETWORK FOR ALTERNATIVES TO PSYCHIATRY

    LAMBETH LINK FORUM

    HACKNEY MENTAL HEALTH ACTION GROUP

    CAMDEN MENTAL HEALTH CONSORTIUM

    BRIGHTON INSIGHT/THRESHOLD

    CONTACT (CHESTERFIELD)

    ISLINGTON FORUM MCMURPHYS (SHEFFIELD)

    MANCHESTER MIND

    CAMDEN MIND

    MENTAL HEALTH SYSTEM SURVIVORS

    PEOPLE NOT PSYCHIATRY (PNP)

    SURVIVORS SPEAK OUT

    MIND CONSUMER NETWORK (MINDLINK)

    NAN/ UKAN ( NATIONAL/UK ADVOCACY NETWORK)

    MAD PRIDE

    VOICES FORUM (PERCEPTIONS)

    HEARING VOICES NETWORK

    PARANOIA NETWORK

    SCOTTISH USERS NETWORK

    SCOTTISH ASSOCIATION FOR MENTAL HEALTH

    MENTAL HEALTH MEDIA

    EUROPEAN NETWORK OF USERS AND SURVIVORS OF PSYCHIATRY

    WORLD FEDERATION OF PSYCHIATRIC USERS

    INTERVOICE

    COME OFF IT (TRANQULLISER ACTION GROUP)

    COUNCIL FOR INVOLUNTARY TRANQUILLISERACTION (CITA)

    ECT ANONYMOUS

    WOMEN IN SPECIAL HOSPITALS (WISH)

    ASSOCIATION OF SURVIVOR WORKERS

    SURVIVOR RESEARCH NETWORK

    WORKING TO RECOVERY

    COOL TAN ARTS

    CRITICAL PSYCHIATRY NETWORK

    FURTHER MENTION OF ORGANISATIONS IN COLLECTION OF ASYLUM MAGAZINES


    ACTIONB Booklets , reports, conference flyers.

    interview SAMPLE documentary.

  • CHARTER OF RIGHTS FOR PEOPLE IN MENTAL DISTRESS.
    Hackney Mental Health Action Group.

  • CHARTER 90. Lambeth Forum

  • MENTAL HEALTH PRIORITIES IN CAMDEN AS WE SEE THEM
    Camden Consortium

  • FIT FOR CONSUMPTION. Islington Forum

  • WOMEN AND SELF INJURY.
    Bristol crisis Service for Women

  • WOMEN AND DEPRESSION. LET'S START TALKING.
    Islington Forum

  • EDALE CHARTER OF NEEDS AND DEMANDS.
    Survivors Speak Out

  • MEETING WITH PSICHIATRIA DEMOCRATICA.
    Manchester MIND

  • CRISIS CARD/ADVANCE STATEMENTS.

  • PSYCHIATRY WITHOUT TRANQUILLISERS CONFERENCE

  • BEAT THE BENZOS CONFERENCE

  • USERS REPORT ON PSYCHIATRIC SERVICES. /THE CHRONICLE.
    Broadmoor. Janet Cresswell.

  • MENTAL HEALTH TASK FORCE REORTS

  • RECLAIM BEDLAM.

  • PROTEST AGAINST PROPOSED REFORM OF MENTAL HEALTH ACT 1983.

  • KISS IT! XX CAMPAIGN AGAINST PSYCHIATRIC ASSAULT.

  • CAMPAIGN FOR THE ABOLITION OF THE SCHIZOPHRENIA LABEL

  • TRUTH AND RECONCILATION IN PSYCHIATRY.

  • Crisis internet petition Card

    Peter Campbell who scripted the drama to the C4 documentary 1987 We're Not mad, We're Angry being interviewed by the local paper Ham and High with a poster of Hackney Mental Health Action Group behind him.
    ".in the end, after two years hard work by 20 'mentally ill' people we had made a coherent documentary - most normal people can't say that."

    Rhythm of Struggle and Song of Hope produced by the Campaign Against Psychiatric Oppression which, like PROMPT before it, raised money through 'benefits' held in pubs and other venues.

    The Chronicle was produced in Broadmoor.

    Janet Cresswell was one of the contributors


  • Press cuttings. There is letter from Peter Campbell to the Guardian . I feel I should declare that I have been diagnosed with manic depression with schizophrenic tendencies.While this description may have helped the experts in prescribing numerous "drug cocktails" over the years it is not proved a notable success on the dance floors of life.


  • We're not Mad. We're Angry. Statements by Survivors.

  • Fighters for Change. Louise Pembroke

  • Forced into Poverty-Kept in Distress. Peter Beresford.

  • Participation and Power. Vivien Lindow.

  • Winning through against fear and contempt. Jan Wallcraft

  • The Challenge of Self-Advocacy. Anne Plumb

  • A New day Dawning. Peter Beresford

  • Psychosis . The Ultimate Reality. Janice Hartley

  • Working to Recover.y A Bad career move. Ron Coleman.

  • Meal times. Niall

  • The Last Communication

  • It's not the Real you+

  • Clocked Off. Peter Campbell

  • User-led Research. Alison Faulkner and Vicky Nicholls

  • Thinking about a drug free future. Jim Read.

  • I've just read I have no empathy. So how come I care. Clare Allan


    I have a great many articles listed - along with ones noted in Asylum magazine over the years. My set of Asylum magazine is a significant record as survivor/service user contributions and notification of activities were encouraged. Also useful for dating events! Early leaflets etc were often not dated or sourced.


    SURVIVOR HISTORY GROUP

    The Survivor History Group was set up in 2006 to record, preserve, collate and make widely available the diversity and creativity of service users/survivors through personal accounts, writings, poetry, art''music d,rama, photography .and all other expressions

    Associated with the SHG is Andrew Roberts Mental Health and Survivor History Website www.studymore.org.uk/mpu.htm Andrew was secretary of the Mental Patients Union when it was founded in 1972 and involved with Hackney MPU and Hackney Mental Health Action Group (Charter of Rights for Mentally Distressed people 1986)

    And a forum which varies in its activity but has drawn activists and others together

    Varied archives held by members. Eg Tower Hamlets Caribbean and African Mental Health Association, UKAN (UK Advocacy Network).Threatened as organisations fold.

    Visit to CAPS (Consultation and Advocacy Promotion Service) Edinburgh Substantial Archive and Oor Mad History, A Community History of the Lothian Mental Health Service User Movement,

    Potential links with the archive of the European Network of Users and Survivors of Psychiatry. (ENUSP)


    If history is a story that purports to be true, we should ask how the story relates to the evidence about what happened. This chapter argues that some of the alleged facts in published histories of the survivors' movement do not correspond with evidence from the archives and examines how some of the stories conflict with memories of those who took part in the events We review the main printed academic works on general survivor history, focusing on empirical credibility, and conclude by arguing that the collective archiving and story telling of the Survivors History Group has a positive part to play in the creation of an objective history that is true to the memories of many different people and fits the evidence in preserved records We outline the principles behind our Survivors History.

    We point to two features which have tended to make survivor histories different from other people's histories. A difference that stands out is that our histories are usually descriptive rather than theoretical We discuss the significance of this difference Less obvious, but one that we try to explain in the article, is that survivor research has focused on the continuity of survivor action instead of considering it a by product of intellectual trends, such as Laingian anti-psychiatry We argue that this corresponds more closely to the reality of what happened As Louise Pembroke has said, we were not "sitting around talking about Laing" - "our role models were each other" (email 20.7.2009).

    From " Survivor History Group Takes a Critical Look at Historians. In Marian Barnes and Phil Cotteril (2011). Critical Perspectives on the User Movement.

    SURVIVOR HISTORY GROUP www.studymore.co.uk


  •